Fall is a season of cozy sweaters, pumpkin spice lattes, and—let’s face it—an avalanche of autumn-themed decor flooding our homes. While many of us eagerly embrace the charm of fall with gourds, garlands, and glittery accents, interior designers often cringe at some of the most popular seasonal decorations. Why? Because these overused items can quickly make your space feel cliché, cluttered, or just plain tacky.

If you’re looking to elevate your fall decor game this year, here are six classic fall decorations that professional designers actually hate—and what you should use instead for a more sophisticated seasonal touch.

1. Plastic Pumpkins Everywhere

Why Designers Hate Them:

Plastic pumpkins might be affordable and easy to store, but they lack authenticity and texture. They scream “cheap” and can overwhelm a space when used excessively.

What to Use Instead:

  • Real or Faux Wooden Pumpkins: Opt for wooden, ceramic, or matte-finish faux pumpkins in neutral tones like cream, taupe, or charcoal.
  • Natural Gourds: Incorporate real squash or gourds in muted shades for an organic, earthy vibe.

Designer Tip:

Less is more. A few strategically placed pumpkins on a mantel or dining table look far more intentional than scattering them throughout every room.

2. Glittery Leaf Garlands

Why Designers Hate Them:

Glitter may seem festive, but it often looks cheap and out of place in modern interiors. Plus, glitter has a way of shedding everywhere, creating unnecessary mess.

What to Use Instead:

  • Eucalyptus or Olive Branch Garlands: These natural elements bring warmth and elegance without overwhelming your space.
  • Dried Floral Wreaths: Choose wreaths made from dried leaves, pampas grass, or wheat for a rustic yet refined look.

Designer Tip:

Stick to materials that mimic nature’s textures, such as burlap, linen, or preserved botanicals, for a timeless aesthetic.

3. Orange and Black Color Schemes

Why Designers Hate Them:

While orange and black are traditional Halloween colors, they can feel harsh and overly themed when used beyond October 31st. This combo limits the versatility of your decor.

What to Use Instead:

  • Warm Neutrals with Pops of Rust or Mustard: Think creamy whites, warm browns, and soft grays paired with subtle hints of burnt orange or deep mustard yellow.
  • Earthy Tones with Metallic Accents: Add touches of gold, copper, or bronze for a luxurious autumnal glow.

Designer Tip:

Focus on creating a cohesive palette that transitions seamlessly from fall into winter, avoiding anything too holiday-specific.

4. Cheesy “Harvest Blessings” Signs

Why Designers Hate Them:

Mass-produced signs with generic phrases like “Give Thanks” or “Welcome Fall” lack personality and originality. They can also feel impersonal and kitschy.

What to Use Instead:

  • Custom Artwork or Calligraphy: Commission a local artist to create something unique, or try your hand at DIY calligraphy.
  • Vintage Finds: Scour flea markets or antique shops for vintage frames or artwork that fits the season.

Designer Tip:

Incorporate meaningful quotes or family names into your decor for a personal touch that feels intentional and special.

5. Over-the-Top Hay Bales

Why Designers Hate Them:

Hay bales may evoke images of charming farmhouses, but indoors, they can attract dust, bugs, and even mold—not exactly ideal for a cozy home environment.

What to Use Instead:

  • Woven Baskets or Rattan Pieces: Bring in natural textures through woven baskets, rattan chairs, or jute rugs.
  • Wooden Crates: Stack wooden crates filled with blankets or seasonal produce for a functional yet stylish display.

Designer Tip:

If you must use hay outdoors, keep it minimal and pair it with sleek, modern elements to balance the rustic vibe.

6. Fake Candles with Flickering Lights

Why Designers Hate Them:

Battery-operated candles with flickering flames often look artificial and distracting. Their inconsistent glow can detract from the cozy ambiance you’re trying to create.

What to Use Instead:

  • Real Pillar Candles: Use unscented pillar candles in varying heights for a clean, elegant look.
  • LED Candles with Subtle Glow: If safety is a concern, choose high-quality LED candles with a steady, warm light.

Designer Tip:

Cluster candles of different sizes together for visual interest, and place them near reflective surfaces like mirrors or metallic trays to amplify their glow.

Final Thoughts

Decorating for fall doesn’t have to mean sacrificing style for sentimentality. By swapping out overdone, clichéd items for thoughtful, elevated alternatives, you can celebrate the season while maintaining a chic and inviting home. As someone who once proudly displayed glitter-covered leaves and plastic jack-o’-lanterns, I’ve learned that simplicity and intentionality go a long way in creating a space that feels both seasonal and sophisticated.

So this fall, take a cue from the pros and skip the gimmicky decor. Instead, focus on natural textures, muted color palettes, and personalized touches that reflect your unique taste. Your home—and your guests—will thank you!